Face-up size, the bow-tie, and what these shapes cost at our Foreshore counter.
Quick answer: All three look bigger per carat than a round, and that’s usually why people choose them. Right now about 60% of the engagement rings I make are fancy shapes and 40% rounds. The cut decides whether that extra face-up size is a bargain or a dull stone with a dark band across the middle, called a bow-tie. We buy South African rough and cut and polish it ourselves, including all three of these shapes. Fancy shapes are on average about 30% less than a comparable round. As a 1ct H colour, SI clarity ballpark, VAT included, at the moment: a round is about R60,000, an oval or pear about R42,000, and a marquise about R46,000. GIA doesn’t yet give these shapes an overall cut grade; that’s coming in 2027. Until then, you have to look at the stone. For a custom ring in time for December, last orders are 20 November.

Most people who sit down at our counter for an engagement ring have already decided on a shape, or they think they have. These days it’s very often an oval, a pear or a marquise. They’re beautiful, they look generous on the hand, and they cost less than a round. But they’re also the shapes where I see the biggest difference between a well-cut stone and a badly cut one. So here’s what I’d want you to know before you choose.
Oval, pear and marquise at a glance
| Oval | Pear | Marquise | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outline | Soft, elongated egg | Round at one end, a point at the other | Long, with a point at each end |
| On the hand | Elegant, lengthens the finger | Distinctive, a little vintage | Bold, the longest look |
| Face-up size vs a round of the same carat | Larger | Larger | Largest |
| Bow-tie risk | Can show one | Higher on a poor cut | Higher on a poor cut |
| Weak point | None | The point | Both points |
| How it’s set | Claws or bezel | V-claw on the point | V-claws on both points |
| 1ct H/SI ballpark, VAT incl., at the moment | about R42,000 | about R42,000 | about R46,000 |
For comparison, a 1ct H/SI round is about R60,000 at the moment. These are ballparks, not quotes; every stone is priced on its own grades and cut.



Why they look bigger than a round, and when they don’t
Carat is weight, not size. An elongated outline spreads that weight over a longer face, so an oval, pear or marquise usually looks larger than a round of the same carat, and it makes the finger look slimmer too.
The catch is depth. A stone cut too deep holds its weight underneath, where nobody sees it. You pay for the carat on paper and get a smaller, darker diamond on the hand. If you’re only comparing two shapes, my earlier post on oval vs round diamonds covers that side by side.
The bow-tie, and why cut matters more on these shapes
A bow-tie is a dark band running across the middle of the stone, from side to side. It happens when light leaks out of the centre of an elongated diamond instead of coming back to your eye.
A faint bow-tie is common, and in a well-cut oval it can even add contrast. A heavy one is a cut problem, and it’s most obvious in a badly cut pear or marquise.
Put two pears of the same weight and grade side by side and the difference is obvious: the well-cut one shows light right across the middle, while the poorly cut one has a dark band from side to side that no photo flatters. That band is the bow-tie, and it’s why we always show you the stone face-up, in more than one light, before you choose.

Length to width. Keep this practical. An oval often sits around 1.3 to 1.5 times as long as it is wide, a pear around 1.5 to 1.75, and a marquise longer, often around 1.75 to 2.2. Taste varies. The stone on your hand wins over any number.
What GIA’s 2027 cut grade changes, and what it doesn’t
Today a GIA report on an oval, pear or marquise grades polish and symmetry, but gives no overall cut grade. GIA has said it will introduce cut grades for these three shapes in 2027 (Rapaport, 14 June 2026).
That’s good news for buyers later on. It doesn’t grade the stone you’re looking at this month. Until the new grade exists, you still need to see the diamond. Our stones are GIA and EGL certified, and we’ll walk you through what the report says and what you need to judge with your own eyes.
See them side by side
Come and look at an oval, a pear and a marquise at the Diamond Bar
15th Floor, Standard Bank South Towers, 13 Hertzog Blvd, Foreshore, Cape Town · Mon–Fri 9:00–16:00, closed weekends.
What these shapes cost at our counter
- Fancy shapes are on average about 30% less than rounds, because the rough usually yields better for them.
- 1ct H/SI ballparks, VAT included, at the moment: round about R60,000; oval and pear about R42,000; marquise about R46,000, about 10% over oval and pear.
- The setting only, made at our partner jewellery workshop here in Cape Town, VAT included: 9ct about R7,000; 14ct about R10,500; 18ct about R14,200; platinum about R16,000.
The stone is usually most of the ring. For how a whole ring adds up, see how much a natural diamond engagement ring costs in South Africa.
One thing from the trade: very well-cut fancy shapes are hard to find right now and command premiums, while badly proportioned ones are hard to sell (Rapaport Market Comment, 12 November 2026). Another reason to buy the cut, not just the shape.
Setting the points, and resizing after the proposal
The point of a pear and both points of a marquise are the parts most likely to chip, so they need protecting, usually with V-claws or a bezel. Our partner jewellery workshop here in Cape Town does that work. An oval has no points, so it’s the easiest of the three to set and wear.

And if you’re planning a surprise, don’t worry about getting the size perfect in secret. We can resize the ring after the proposal.
If you need it for December
Last custom orders for December are 20 November. After that, a finished ring, a loose certified stone in a mounting, or a proposal with the stone first still works. The showroom is open until 22 December for finished pieces, loose stones and orders for delivery next year, and we reopen on 4 January 2027. The full plan is in our December proposal timeline. Shopping the sales first? Read how to tell if a Black Friday diamond discount is real.
Frequently asked questions
Is an oval or pear cheaper than a round in South Africa?
Yes. At our counter fancy shapes are on average about 30% less than a comparable round. At the moment a 1ct H colour, SI clarity oval or pear is about R42,000 and a marquise about R46,000, against about R60,000 for a round, VAT included. These are ballparks, not quotes.
Are marquise diamonds cheaper than round?
Yes. At the moment a 1ct H/SI marquise is about R46,000 against about R60,000 for a round. That’s about 10% more than an oval or pear (about R42,000), but still well below a round.
Which diamond shape looks the biggest for its carat?
The elongated shapes usually face up larger than a round of the same carat: marquise most, then pear and oval. That only holds if the cut is good. A deep, badly proportioned stone carries its weight underneath, where you can’t see it.
What is a bow-tie in an oval, pear or marquise?
A dark band running across the middle of the stone, shaped like a bow-tie. A faint one is common in elongated brilliants. A heavy one usually means a poor cut, especially on a pear or marquise. Look at the diamond face-up, in person and in more than one light.
Do GIA certificates grade cut on oval, pear and marquise diamonds?
Not yet. Today a GIA report on these shapes gives polish and symmetry, not an overall cut grade. GIA has said a cut grade for oval, pear and marquise is coming in 2027. Until then, the stone in front of you tells you more than the report’s cut line.
Are pear and marquise tips fragile?
The points are the weak spot, so they need protecting, usually with V-claws or a bezel. Our partner jewellery workshop here in Cape Town sets them that way. An oval has no points.
Can I still get a fancy-shape engagement ring before December?
For a custom ring, 20 November is the last-orders date for December. After that we can still help with a finished piece, a loose certified stone in a mounting, or a proposal with the stone first. Rings can be resized after the proposal. The showroom is open until 22 December and reopens 4 January 2027.
See all three in the showroom
Choosing between an oval, a pear and a marquise?
WhatsApp me the shape you’re considering, or book a time to see all three side by side in the showroom.
15th Floor, Standard Bank South Towers, 13 Hertzog Blvd, Foreshore, Cape Town · Mon–Fri 9:00–16:00, closed weekends. December orders by 20 Nov · open until 22 Dec · back 4 Jan 2027.
Related reading: Oval vs round diamonds · Engagement ring cost guide · December proposal timeline · Black Friday diamond discounts
About the author
Marten Cross is a diamanteer at The Diamond Shoppe in Cape Town. His father started in the diamond industry in 1972, and the family has more than fifty years of craft behind it. Marten selects GIA & EGL-certified natural diamonds for clients at the Diamond Bar.

